Speaking as someone who has consciously opted out of religion, has better things to do than contemplate faith, and is a self-confessed "kinda strange guy"...
That logo is more than a wee bit off kilter. The phrase I would use in polite company would probably be "remarkably doofy", because that's how I roll. But, "a bit too weird" works very well also ;) Sorry, but that one looks very much fated for a one-way ticket to /dev/null. Try, try again! (Speaking as an artist, which I am -- I throw away tons more than I keep. Oh -- and people tell me I'm pretty dang good. I'm not interested in arguing...)